The Gambia’s politics and political culture: Principle and pragmatism have given way to self interest

Share

1 October 2026

By Dr. Omar Janneh

Political disagreement is normal, and indeed essential, to a functioning democracy. However, we are developing what should be a worrying political culture in The Gambia: principle and pragmaticism seem increasingly subordinate to personal or political interests. I think this is what some commentators have aptly described political enterprise and it seems we have a few political entrepreneurs in the country. Too many of our political actors appear less concerned with building credible institutions, strengthening democratic norms or leaving a political culture that outlives them; one that future generations can be proud to inherit, nurture and sustain. Our political actors seem to point to being more interested in getting, as they probably see it- a share of the national pie, and or in securing their own political relevance, influence or position. In my mind’s eye, the result is a kind of politics that appears transactional rather than transformational. Sadly, the Gambian public forgives it.

In The Gambia, politicians criticise the administration when they are outside government and, when probably offered a place within it, suddenly discover reasons to support the very administration they previously strongly condemned. It seems clear that the political actors attack the Barrow administration- presumably to get noticed- while simultaneously pursuing arrangements, on the sidelines, that appear more to secure political advantage than to advance a coherent national programme, a programme that addresses the legitimate aspirations of Gambians. This is not only disappointing, but corrosive to public confidence in politics and the construction of a sound political culture on which democratic principles can be built.

From my perspective, for good reason, the Barrow administration has attracted criticism on a wide range of issues, and I have written about many of these in the past. However, what is striking is that some of the strongest criticisms have come from political who have subsequently joined, or sought to work with, the administration. These criticisms have been broad and, in some cases, severe. Yes, I have had my own thrown in his direction too. Among many criticisms, they have accused the administration of being wasteful with scarce public resources, ineffective and clueless in delivering development, excessive in political appointments, the opening of embassies and a seemingly endless list of advisers and insufficiently committed to institutional reforms. Questions have also been raised about the quality and value of infrastructure projects, the management of the electricity sector, the treatment of farmers, dilapidated healthcare facilities, and the failure to implement important recommendations emerging from commissions of inquiry.

I do not believe these criticisms can be simply discarded on the basis that some of those who made them have now tilted towards Barrow. I think their subsequent decisions make an important question unavoidable to callout: So, were their earlier criticisms genuinely held convictions, or were they simply political weapons deployed while they were outside government, only for their voices to be neutralised when they were subsequently brought into the administration? I know none of them will answer this question, but I think it needs to be asked.

Yes, governments should be judged partly by what they build and there is nothing wrong with pointing to roads, electricity connections or other infrastructure as evidence of development. However, development cannot be measured simply by counting projects, laying foundation stones of projects or on promises. I think a powerful illustration of this is the recent and ongoing electricity crisis. Connecting more homes and businesses to the grid is meaningful only if there is sufficient generating and distribution capacity to provide reliable electricity. I think there is little comfort in giving citizens wires that do not consistently bring light to their homes, businesses, and healthcare facilities. Understandably, a household may be encouraged to abandon candles, and invest in appliances, but prolonged power cuts will make it impossible to preserve the food they spent a lot of money on. The consequences are far more than inconvenience: spoiled food, wasted money and increased household costs, including the expense of replacing appliances damaged by an unreliable electricity supply-since in our country customers have no recourse to seek compensation from NAWEC, while broken and discarded appliances accumulate in a country that is not adequately equipped to recycle them. Development must be measured by outcomes, reliability and sustainability, not merely by the number of connections, projects, foundation stones laid, promises or ceremonies held at state house.

The treatment of farmers raises another fundamental question. For years, Gambian farmers have been promised greater support, better agricultural input and improved conditions. Yet many continue to face difficulties, and low productivity that make farming increasingly precarious and without adequate returns to sustain life. A country that cannot meet its basic food supply leaves its citizens dangerously exposed to external shocks/upheaval. Farmers must learn to tilt away from a government that remains in power for close to a decade yet treats agricultural difficulties as if they are exclusively inherited problems. At some point, responsibility for delivering on the promises made to the agricultural sector can no longer be attributed to inherited problems; it must become part of the government’s own political legacy. Sadly, ours do not seem to be the type that give some thought to building a commendable legacy.

Perhaps even more troubling is this:  The Gambia has spent considerable public resources on commissions of inquiry, investigations and reform processes. The Janneh Commission, the Faraba Commission and the Truth, Reconciliation and Reparations Commission (TRRC) all generated findings and recommendations of considerable public interest and importance. [Some would know that I have been a consistent harsh critic of aspects of the TRRC, and I continue to have reservations about the robustness of some of its appointments and processes, including some of the questions I have raised about potential conflicts of interest involving some appointees and the implications these may have for perceptions of independence, impartiality and reparations. While the victims continue to wait for the implementation of the Commission’s recommendations, the handler of the YouTube videos containing the TRRC proceedings continues to benefit from the clicks generated by them. While the recent agreement between The Gambia and the United States on the transfer and use of funds recovered from the forfeiture of former President Yahya Jammeh’s property in Potomac, Maryland, for reparations to victims of his regime is significant, we shall see how much of these funds will actually reach the victims for whom they are intended and whether their use will be managed transparently, accountably, and in accordance with the commitments made. What about the proceeds from the forfeiture and sale of Jammeh’s assets in The Gambia? What has happened to those funds, and how much, if any, has been allocated towards reparations for victims? So, the second “R”, reparations- by an unbothered or uncommitted administration- remain one of the most tangible tests of whether the TRRC process will ultimately deliver for the victims and the nation]. A democracy does not become stronger simply because it establishes commissions. In The Gambia, we have a worrying gap between the production of recommendations and their implementation. The government is weak because it fails to act upon credible findings, explain openly why particular recommendations are accepted or rejected, and fails to ensure that institutions are reformed and strengthened to avoid a repeat of past failures.

Considerable time, expertise and public resources went into the drafting of a new Constitution. Yet the 1997 Constitution remains in force. As a staunch critic, I do not think the political leadership has been sufficiently committed to constitutional reform since 2017; the existing constitutional arrangements are and have been politically convenient. However, I do not think a constitution should be treated as something to be changed or preserved according to the immediate interests of anyone who happens to be in power.

Another feature that seems characteristically pervasive in Gambian politics is the perception that political loyalty can matter more than competence. A leadership that works on the basis that a state can be efficiently governed if appointments are primarily underpinned by political loyalty and convenience is headed in the wrong direction. The capacity of government cannot be strengthened indefinitely by creating more patronage-based positions, appointing more advisers and expanding the machinery surrounding political leadership. At some point, one must ask whether everyone is doing something useful; are too many people simply occupying positions around the centre of power, costing the nation too much while many critical sectors such as health, agriculture and more remain unattended to? In our case, it is clear a government surrounded by more advisers does not necessarily become a government bestowed with better advice. It is well known that excessive reliance on consultants and advisers can weaken the state if the expertise acquired is not transferred into the permanent institutions of government (The Big Con by Mariana Mazzucato & Rosie Collington). And there is a further problem: when consultants produce reports that subsequently sit on shelves gathering dust, the country loses: it pays for the advice it cannot deliver as it does not have the institutional capacity that the advice was supposed to develop and it fails to capture- in house- the lessons learnt during the work of the consultants who work external to government. Consultancy should strengthen government capacity, not substitute for it (The Big Con by Mariana Mazzucato & Rosie Collington).

The Barrow administration came to power on a Change ticket, but it is now working on the agenda of entrenchment. It seems our politics has given birth to an unfortunate tendency to transform the change we voted for into a system determined to entrench itself, with the cross-carpeting of opposition political actors providing perhaps the clearest evidence of what is an ugly transformation of our politics. This is the unfortunate ironies of the current Gambian political experience. The Barrow administration came to power after a period of intense public dissatisfaction with the previous political order, yet it seems fair for me to criticise it as being increasingly adopting some of the very political practices that Gambians expected to leave behind. For most fair-minded Gambians, I think the administration’s relationship with figures associated with the former Yahya Jammeh era is particularly difficult for many to understand and stomach. The public already knew much about the excesses of the Jammeh years even before the TRRC. The Janneh Commission and subsequently the TRRC provided further institutional documentation and testimony concerning the abuses, financial wrongdoing and damage associated with that period. Thus, I think it is understandable that many Gambians find it difficult to reconcile the language of political renewal with alliances or appointments involving individuals associated with the former order. December 2026 will reveal if Gambians have had enough of the jazz.

As we move closer to December 2026, the political manoeuvring and messaging seems profoundly confusing. Most know the old system to be wrong, but I wonder why some of the people associated with that wrong system now politically useful. I find this to be an extraordinary journey of the Gambian political class. Nowhere is the weakness of political principle and pragmatism more visible than in the phenomenon of political cross-carpeting. First, it must be said, crossing the political floor is not new. Political realignment happens in democracies everywhere. Politicians change parties, governments form coalitions and political circumstances evolve. But there is something particularly troubling when a politician spends years describing a government in deeply critical terms, only to join that same government when the political opportunity seems to arise. The issue is not that politicians are prohibited from changing their minds; of course, one can change one’s mind when circumstances change. However, it is unclear what has changed in the way and direction Barrow leads the country. The issue is they do not explain why they changed their minds. You see, if an administration was corrupt, wasteful, incompetent and fundamentally unfit to govern yesterday, what has (sufficiently) changed today to warrant supporting and joining that inept, and corrupt administration? Has the administration fundamentally changed? What facts have changed? Which of its policies have changed? Or has the politician's political calculation changed? I think the Gambian public deserve answers to these basic questions.

We seem to be witnessing a predictable pattern of critics turning into government insiders: a politician outside government criticises the Barrow and his administration. The politician attracts attention and establishes a reputation as an alternative voice. Government then reaches out. An appointment or political accommodation follows. Then, suddenly, the critic grows a different tongue- their language unashamedly changes. This has happened, in different ways, to several political actors, including Dr Ismaila Ceesay, Mr Mai Fatty, Mr Mama Kandeh, Mr. Essa M Faal, and Prof. Sidat Yaffa. The problem is what effects do their actions have on the credibility of our political actors and political culture? One unintended consequence of their actions, however, is that they provide rich material for the creative arts. Comedians and musicians have turned their criticisms of the administration into satire, songs and e-cartoons, often using animals such as dogs, donkeys and squirrels to caricature and ridicule those who once criticised Barrow but later joined his party. When political actors abandon positions on which they have built their prominence or for which they have become known, without adequately explaining the reasons for such a change of heart, they risk inviting critics and the public to conclude that their earlier opposition was motivated less by principle and pragmatism than by political positioning and the pursuit of self-interest. This is deeply damaging to the creation of political culture and the emergence of democratic norms. A politician who changes political direction risks becoming what I would not hesitate to uncharitably describe as political rotisserie, turning whichever direction the political milk and honey happens to flow from.

It seems our politics is reduced to survival, putting food on the table. It seems some political actors are either inadvertently or deliberately developing a political culture in which personalities sometimes matter more than building credible institutions. Our politicians build personal followings. We create political parties around individuals. Political criticism can become intensely personal, while serious discussion of policy, institutions and implementation receives considerably less attention or none. Worryingly, the public seem less bothered by this. Perhaps unfair, but out of frustration, I will put it like this: if there is pageantry and the beating of the drum and dance, the Gambian public is happy.

Our political discourse often becomes theatrical, usually worse– mudslinging. The politicians can call the government incompetent, corrupt, incapable. Yet when political circumstances change, the same actors find themselves sitting comfortably within the very establishment they previously condemned. If this does not breed cynicism within our body politic, then it is difficult to imagine what would. Cynicism is dangerous because it can lead to citizens eventually stop believing anyone.

Overall, we have an opposition that has yet to master the mathematics of politics. It is not enough to describe your political leadership as intelligent, experienced or principled. Political intelligence must produce political results. The opposition parties have too often demonstrated an inability to understand what might be called the law of addition. In politics, addition matters; that is what removed Jammeh, yet we seem to be looking for the key to this problem in a place we have not lost the key. If several opposition forces with broadly similar objectives and I think they do, their ability to combine their strengths should make them stronger than any one of them individually. We call this in my line of work ‘synergism’; their work should not ‘antagonise’ each other. Unfortunately, the Gambian opposition seem to master the art of subtraction, fragmentation, pursuing personal ambition and rivalry/antagonism, leaving them weak and vulnerable to humiliating defeat; the opposition fails to harness what could be its collective strength. Close observation of the opposition appears to show that they are unable to offer one another enough common ground to come together. Even the question of what to call their coming together can become a source of tension, friction, suspicion, further division and fragmentation. I think that says a lot about the depth of the challenge facing the Gambia’s opposition and our political culture. Yes, most of us do understand that names and labels do matter. Names can carry history, identity, pride and political meaning. However, I think there are moments in the life of a nation, as obtains now, when we must be prepared to put some of those considerations aside for a greater purpose- the country is at a critical juncture. Allow me to put it crudely like this: when the country is on fire, the priority should not be arguing over what to call the fire brigade. Let’s agree to call it what we like: collaboration, platform, coalition, alliance, movement, partnership or something else if it brings the political actors and the electorate together to put out the fire. At some point, political actors must decide whether the name matters more than the national purpose their party or movement seeks to serve. The country cannot afford a kind of politics in which the search for the perfect label becomes another reason why those who claim to want change remain fragmented.

While Barrow seems clueless in the delivery of the functions of state, he and the team (strategists?) appear to understand the arithmetic of addition; they turn the weakness of the opposition in their favour. They have repeatedly demonstrated that political survival, it seems to become just that for him, depends not simply on defeating opponents but on attracting, accommodating or primarily neutralising them. The opposition, meanwhile, seems determined to make the government's task easier.

We are at a crossroads; our dilemma is bigger than Barrow. The real casualty: political culture and country. It is bigger than NPP, UDP, GFA, Unite/UMC, APRC, NRP, GDC, GMC, CA or any other political organisation or movement. The fundamental question is what kind of political culture do we want to build: Do we want politics to be an enterprise in which individuals move wherever opportunity takes them? Do we want political parties to exist principally as vehicles for personal ambition? Do we want opposition politicians to criticise government until they are noticed and offered positions within it? Do we want public institutions staffed according to political loyalty rather than competence? Do we want expensive commissions whose recommendations are subsequently ignored? Do we want consultants to repeatedly tell government what it already ought to know while the resulting reports gather dust? Or what is it that we want and is it better than what obtains now?

From my perspective, the test of political character is not what a politician says when seeking power. To this point, The Gambia deserves politicians who can say no. I think it is what that a politician is prepared to say when power is offered. A politician who can criticise government from outside but cannot maintain his or her integrity and principles after being invited to state house has not demonstrated the political commitment and maturity for what they once articulated and for why have become known by. Likewise, an opposition party or movement that is prepared to compromise its principles merely to secure political patronage or advantage has not demonstrated principle and pragmatism. Pragmatism without principle is opportunism and principle without pragmatism is political naivety.

The Gambia needs political actors who understand that public office is a responsibility, not a reward. The country needs political parties that can disagree without destroying one another. It needs opposition parties capable of holding the government to account and where necessary, adding their strengths to remove an incompetent regime rather than exposing and multiplying their weaknesses.

The country needs politicians who understand that history is watching; in the minds of some, political memory is longer than political ambition. It is quite possible that the politician who changes position today may secure an appointment tomorrow, but the reverse is also a possible without consequences to Barrow- such is the power of the presidency, our system of governance and the mindset of a people (forgiving/heightened “maslaha” culture and rampant nauseating religiosity). The president can fire, hire and renege on promises without effect. Yes, the party that compromises its principles today may gain a seat at the table tomorrow. However, I very much hope that Gambians will eventually ask not merely who held office, but what they stood for before they entered office, what they did after entering office, and whether they remained true to the principles on which they sought the public's trust. That is the standard by which political leadership should ultimately be judged. Afterall, the country needs a government prepared to deliver on the promises it sold to the electorate; and implement the recommendations of public inquiries. It needs appointments based on competence. It needs institutional reforms and institutions with the requisite knowledge to function. To realise these and address the many failures and shameful decay in the country, the Gambia does not merely need a new breed of politicians, it needs a new political culture rooted in honesty, integrity, discipline and a sharp focus on public service for the good of all. The Gambia needs both principled and pragmatic politicians. If these seem unachievable desires, it is because the seeds may be a rare commodity.

Read more