The cost of The Gambia’s long shadow of institutional indifference, incompetence and failure of leadership
4 November 2026
By Dr. Omar Janneh
While in Primary school, my father would occasionally send me to his uncle in Bakau. On those journeys, I would pass Gambia High School. As the passenger vehicles approached the school, I would admire the smartly dressed students and the school crest on the wall. Since I did not frequent Banjul much in those days and did not see any other high school, this was the high school I desperately wanted to attend. But, because of the difficulties associated with finding accommodation in the Greater Banjul Area, my father and my uncle thought I would be better off attending Armitage High School, a boarding school. I was not particularly enthusiastic about the idea of going to Armitage. Some of those familiar with my school years would remember this: having overcome the hurdle of gaining admission to high school through the Common Entrance Examinations, I spent my first five years of high education (forms 1–5) at Armitage. Until I reached form 4, I hated it at Armitage and complained, at every opportunity, to my father and anyone I thought had influence to support my request to move. I can remember the occasion when my father visited. It gave me an opportunity to display my dissatisfaction of being at Armitage. Although he appeared visibly sympathetic to the challenges of Armitage, what he offered was advise and encouragement that I should persevere, explaining that it would be asking too much of family members to accommodate me in the Greater Banjul Area. Armitage taught me a great deal. I made some life-long friends across the country and in the process acquired wonderful families whom I remain indebted for making the experience truly memorable.
After completing form 5, my uncle encouraged me to proceed to the 6th form, but I developed a rather different perspective of Armitage by the time I started 6th form. When I started the 6th form, I truly wished I could complete my A-levels at Armitage. Reminiscing now, I do not recall anyone having to walk more than 800 metres to get to their classrooms. Yes, Armitage was a crazy institution with many of its “administrative practices” that never made sense to me, but which we had follow. For example: I can recall the slogan: “obey and complain”. If you did not obey, you could find yourself between a rock and hard place; and there is no need to complain as it got you nowhere. The hardships I endured during my 6th form years at Gambia High School, against a backdrop of pervasive and seemingly institutionalised inequality, were considerably greater.
As A-level students, we frequently waited for school buses that either arrived late, never arrived or were frequently already too full to accommodate additional students; the public transport (GPTC busses) was also either late, absent or too full. Consequently, it was regular to arrive late for lessons. And since we wore long trousers in the 6th form, many of us who were in the same situation would arrive at school looking filthy– following a scramble to get onto overcrowded buses or having to clamber into lorries or any vehicle. It was not unusual to hail any passing any vehicle, hoping that a driver would take pity on us and give us a lift to school or home. This one is particularly memorable: to improve our chances of getting a lift home after school, a few friends and I would go to the National Library and spend about two hours trying to study- on empty stomachs; believing that the competition to get a lift home would be less, we would later make our way to the main road at around 4 pm, hoping that we would catch a lift from someone travelling in the direction of our homes. Sometimes, our strategy worked. However, on other occasions, there was no such luck. I recall many times having to walk all the way home, either from Jeshwang to Bakau New Town or from the junction leading to Bakau New Town, via Radio Gambia and the Bakau Women's Horticultural Gardens. It was regular to see government ministers drive past us, seemingly oblivious to our predicament. They seem to have no reference point – that they may well have travelled the same road a few years before or that those they seem to be not seeing may be the leaders tomorrow. They appeared not to notice us standing by the roadside, desperately hoping that some merciful motorist would help us get to school. I do not recall them showing any interest in discussing these challenges, let alone seeking ways to address them. Yet, somehow, some of their own children and other relatives seemed not to experience the same difficulties or arrive late for school. Those who lived through those years will probably recognise exactly what I am talking about. It says a lot about the values our leadership possess. Sadly, it appears that the situation today is no better and may even be worse because of the sheer ineptitude of the current leadership. What kind of society do these politicians and policymakers, both then and now, imagine they are creating if by their actions fail to put interests of the people they serve first? What do they expect when people repeatedly experience such glaring, seemingly deliberate inequalities while others enjoy privileges seemingly guaranteed by their connections? From my perspective, it builds resentment, frustration, alienation and, ultimately, hatred for authority and show seeds of discord which lead to a polarised society.
I do not believe that these experiences are inconsequential; they contribute to shaping perception of authority, fairness, public service, public institutions and the society in which we live. When those entrusted with delivering public service in public institutions appears deliberately indifferent to the everyday struggles and legitimate aspirations of ordinary citizens, I do not think they should be surprised, unless they are poor at reading the environment, when they experience erosion of confidence in their leadership.
Now I turn to the recent challenges at the University of The Gambia (UTG); from my perspective, this speak to lack of leadership. In my view, we must situate a significant part of the problem in what appears to have been a leadership challenge with a flawed recruitment and selection process. The wrong person was appointed to the position of Vice-Chancellor (VC), while those responsible for providing subsequent oversight appeared very content to sit on their hands- serving some unknown interests- as the situation deteriorated. This is unacceptable.
I still find this very bizarre: rather than concentrating efforts on making the existing university functional, those in positions of authority appear obsessed/preoccupied with turning virtually every institution into a university. This is not an example of intelligent leadership. It is leadership without a clear sense of purpose or priorities. It should be clear that for some time now, UTG has been struggling with fundamental operational challenges. This makes it clear that establishing and sustaining a functional university requires considerable resources, engaged and competent leadership, effective administration, sound governance, qualified academic staff, appropriate infrastructure and a commitment to research and scholarly activity that supports teaching and innovation, including the establishment of start-ups. A university is not created simply by conferring university status on an institution. In my view, I think it would make more sense to concentrate on making UTG work properly before embarking on further expansion.
It appears that those responsible for recruitment have little appreciation of what effective institutional leadership requires. So, one is left wondering whether the recruitment panel can differentiate between good, bad and ugly, or whether they even understand what constitutes good enough. They appear not to understand the purpose of the VC. Recruitment is not simply about producing an impressive-looking job description. It is easy to tick boxes on person specifications, essential and desirable criteria for the post of VC. It is about doing everything possible, asking relevant and searching questions at interview to help identify and appoint the right person for the job; not any peg in the hole should do. If the right candidate cannot be found, keep looking/advertising. I am not suggesting that this is what happened, but there is little justification for appointing an unsuitable candidate simply because a recruitment exercise has been completed or because someone appears to meet some minimum requirements.
I think those entrusted with oversight responsibilities deserve our scrutiny. In the Gambian context, it is often difficult to establish whose interests such individuals are serving or whether they have the requisite competence, skills, and experience to do the assignment they are entrusted, for which they may be remunerated. And to the Gambian public this is what I have to say: it seems that some observers, even with limited or no experience of university governance, seem only eager or quick to endorse candidates or defend appointments. Questions about what the candidates have built, their relevant track records, their previous achievements and their demonstrated capacity to (lead) and do the job they applied for well seem to receive remarkably little attention. It seems all you need to do to keep a Gambian happy is to promise. Time and again, our reactions to serious problems seem to follow a familiar dance: we seem to have an insatiable appetite for mediocrity and an extraordinary tolerance for the status quo, matched by a very short- term memory.
Leaders who wait until problems become crises before attempting to address them lack one of the essential attributes of leadership: the ability to anticipate, interpret and respond to their environment. Such leaders fail to appreciate that public service is fundamentally about sacrifice, possessing a sense of purpose and an understanding of priorities. What justification is there for university leaders to sit in shiny and air-conditioned offices while students lack access to clean drinking water? What justification is there for them to drive expensive vehicles to work, passing students stranded at bus stops because the university buses that should transport them to and from lectures have failed to arrive? Do they have eyes that cannot see? I do not think engaged and competent leaders wait until students, staff or somebody demand action before addressing problems that seem or are already evident. They possess intuition, instinct and recognise their responsibilities and act in a timely fashion.
Evidence suggests the UGT’s Conditions of Service provides for the VC’s performance to be appraised, and the outcome reported to the Office of the President by 14 October 2026. In preparation for the exercise, the VC was invited to complete the approved assessment form and submit supporting evidence of his achievements, challenges and performance to the Governing Council by 12 October 2026. However, the VC failed to do this by the deadline, questioned the Governing Council's authority to conduct the exercise and indicated his unwillingness to participate in the process.
In any university, the students and staff make up an important community in its work and life. Their interests are central to every major decision of any functional university. For the students, the quality of experience offered, the quality of teaching and learning conditions placed at their disposal, and their welfare (physical, and mental) should be at the heart of the educational mission of a university. Similarly, staff welfare, fair employment practices, and inclusive professional development are indispensable to effective teaching, research, administration and sharing of good practice.
However, based on the exercise conducted by the Governing Council, the concerns emerging from the UTG seem to suggest some basic issues have not received the attention they deserve. Assessors raised questions about the completion, approval and implementation of the UTG's strategic plan. Meanwhile, the UTG Faculty and Staff Association (UTGFSA) reported that the VC had neither acknowledged nor responded to the resolutions adopted and submitted on 28 September 2026 at its 16 July 2026 Congress. Outstanding demands include a review of staff salaries and increments, compliance with the conditions of service of retirees in administrative positions, staff welfare as well as other institutional concerns. A matter that is worth noting is the fact that while continuing to pursue dialogue, the UTGFSA considered industrial action in their letter dated 28 October 2026, to the Commissioner of the Department of Labour (https://foroyaa.net/utg-staff-association-give-department-of-labour-notice-of-possible-industrial-action/). One can only imagine the consequences of industrial action by the membership of UTGFSA on teaching and learning, and academic progression.
It seems not so obvious to the leadership of the UTG and its oversight institution that it is impossible for any university to fulfil its educational mission when the basic conditions necessary for teaching and learning are absent. The students need reliable transport to and from lectures, access to safe drinking water, appropriate teaching and learning facilities, and an environment in which they can learn and concentrate on their studies. Equally, lecturers and other staff members need to feel valued, respected and adequately supported. When staff are demoralised, when their legitimate concerns cannot even be listened to or their concerns go unanswered, and when university management appears unresponsive to the concerns of student and staff- at the same time-, the consequences inevitably extend beyond individual grievances. They undermine institutional morale, weaken confidence in the governance of the university and compromise the university's core educational purpose.
So, the student protests (https://youtu.be/xM5IMfFkRgU?is=ypZ6Y2tUhDU5EIXB; https://youtu.be/xM5IMfFkRgU?is=CSG8JAZp_mfq8NAg; https://youtu.be/iwk5vtmwk84?is=c4VU3sXtsWiUGGWK; https://alkambatimes.com/utg-students-protest-at-kanifing-campus-demand-vcs-resignation-over-welfare-crisis/) over welfare, transport, water, food and other learning conditions illustrate the seriousness of these concerns. A university's ability to function effectively, balance teaching learning and research, and prepare the next generation of professionals and leaders depend substantially on the welfare of its students and staff. It also depends on inclusive, fair and transparent human-resource practices, inclusive and transparent opportunities for professional development, appropriate working conditions, engaged and effective institutional governance. These are basic requirements of a functional university.
Evidence suggests that the VC's performance was assessed by eleven respondents, producing an average score of 42%. Eight respondents, representing 73%, rated his performance as either poor or fair, with some of the principal concerns relating to strategic leadership, financial accountability, human-resource management, stakeholder engagement and compliance with governance requirements. The VC was lowly rated by the university students and staff. Objectively, these are not institutional disagreements or isolated expressions of dissatisfaction. The issues warrant serious attention from the Office of the President and the responsible Ministry, but I wonder if they have the requisite skills, political will, and competence to address these issues. It should have been clear to any serious and engaged leader that the issues the students and staff raised deserve swift and independent investigations to establish the extent of the problems, identify their underlying causes and determine who should be held accountable. To that end, the VC should have been given an opportunity to explain his position, including why he failed to complete the approved assessment form by the deadline and his objections to the Governing Council's authority to undertake the exercise Overall, tangible actions should have been taken to fix the problems without delay. A clear objective of such an exercise should be made clear to all participating parties: that the exercise is to establish the facts, protect the interests of the constituents (students and staff) and ensure that those entrusted with public responsibilities give due regard to the exercise of their responsibilities and when they fail, they are held accountable. From my perspective, those charged with overseeing the life and work of the UTG seem to have failed the students and staff.
There is a clear leadership failure at UTG which is disturbing. The Governing Council, the responsible Ministry and the Office of the President must each reflect on their respective responsibilities and decide whether they have discharged them adequately. When students are struggling to get to lectures, when staff feel marginalised and demoralised, when legitimate concerns go unanswered and when institutional problems are allowed to deteriorate, serious questions deserve to be asked and answered by those entrusted with those responsibilities; they must be held to account- without delay- when they fail to discharge their duties. This is what speaks to the quality of leadership of any institution and the humanity of those entrusted to discharge public duties.
Leadership is not merely about occupying an office, enjoying the privileges of authority or exercising power over others. It is about being engaged, sacrifice, being purposeful, recognising responsibility, understanding the consequences of decisions and, above all, having the empathy and courage to act when others are suffering- not wait until problems occur and seek to fix them. When a leader/public servant’s eyes fail to see, their ears fail to hear, and their hearts appear incapable of feeling the pain and suffering of others, whether that suffering is written all over their faces or not, something is profoundly wrong with that individual. It may reflect a failure of judgement, betrayal, dishonesty, a deficit of empathy, an absence of public-service ethos, or perhaps, a deeply entrenched sense of entitlement, aversion to discharging the common good and above all utter selfishness. Whatever the explanation, such indifference has consequences. It breeds resentment, destroys confidence, undermines institutions and alienates the very people whom public institutions are supposed to serve. When such selfish disservice to society becomes entrenched, the cycle may become difficult to break; it could lead to a culture of parasitism in which individuals and institutions become accustomed to taking from society without feeling any corresponding obligation to give back anything good. Instead, they contribute to institutional failure and ultimately to a failed state. In essence, no society can build strong institutions on the foundations of pervasive indifference, tilted privileges and unaccountable leadership. Nor can it expect young people to develop faith in public institutions, acquire the requisite skills needed to build a nation when their lived experiences repeatedly teach them that fairness, dignity, worth, hope and opportunity are determined by background, and who you know rather than what you deserve. This is a problem each of us must confront and do something about.